Starters & Appetizers
Garlic Knots- $4.95/8
Our own house recipe of garlic, butter and spices floated over our delicious doughknots!
Garlic Bread- $5.00
Mouthwatering mozzarella cheese melted on top of one of our delicious baguettes.
Chef’s Calamari- $11.75 (Traditional - $9.75)
Lightly floured tubes and tentacles fried with pepperoncini topped in arugula and thai chile.
Stuffed Portabella Mushroom - $8.75
A delicious blend of sausage, spinach & cheese stuffed and baked to perfection.
Meatballs & Ricotta- $6.95/2
Two meatballs surrounded by ricotta cheese.
Chicken Wings- $9.00/10 Boneless- $9.00/5
Served with a side of bleu cheese like it should be, covered with hot sauce, b-b-q, thai chile or honey hot.
Wilbur Wings- $9.00/5
Bone in pork shanks baked with our own brown sugar glaze.
Bacon Wrapped Jalapenos- $8.75/5
Home made fresh jalapenos stuffed with cream cheese wrapped in bacon.
Nacho Fries- $8.95
Steak fries smothered with beef, hatch chili, bacon & cheddar cheese.
Cole Slaw- $3.50 2 Chicken Fingers & Fries- $5.50
Fries-3.50 Grilled Cheese Sandwich & Fries- $5.50
Penne Pasta- $4.50 (add meatball- $1.00) Kid’s Ravioli- $4.50/4
Bowl of Soup- $5.00 Mac & Cheese- $4.50
Veggie of the Day- $4.50
Salads & Such
Slices of fresh mozzarella and tomato with basil & vinaigrette.
Italian Lettuce Wraps- $9.00
Romaine leaves filled with chicken, red onions, kalamata olives, red & green peppers tossed in olive oil garnished with balsamic glaze & grated ricotta salata.
Your choice of today’s combinations.
Chef’s Meat & Cheese Board- $13.00
Enjoy today’s creation of premium Italian meats & cheeses!
Garnished with tomato, olives, pepperoncini, giardinera, artichoke & panino.
With pecorino romano & croutons.
Covered with feta cheese, olives, tomato, cucumber, red onion and pepperoncini.
Lettuce, mozzarella, tomato, cucumber & croutons.
(Your choice of italian, honey mustard, ranch, raspberry vinaigrette or bleu cheese dressing)
(Add chicken - $2.50, steak- $4.50 or shrimp- $5.00)
Hot & Cold Subs & ?
Hot Pastrami on Rye- $8.00
Boar’s head pastrami & swiss with mustard on marbled rye bread)
Meatball Parmigiana- $8.00
Homemade meatballs smothered with sauce & mozzarella.
Sausage with Peppers and Onions- $8.00
Italian sausage covered with sautéed peppers & onions.
Parmigiana ala Nicantoni- $9.75 (veal) $8.75 (chicken)
Breaded tenderized veal or chicken cutlet smothered in sauce & mozzarella.
Grilled Chicken Caprese- $8.50
Grilled chicken breast with fresh mozzarella, tomato & pesto.
Our Philly- $8.75
Sirloin steak strips sautéed with peppers, onions, mushrooms & pepper jack cheese.
Italian Combo- $8.00
Pepperoni, salami, capicollo & provolone cheese, dressing & L-T-O.
Build Your Own Burger- $8.95
Add bacon for .75 or cheese or veggies for .50 each
Ultimate Cheeseburger- $ 9.95
Oozing with swiss, mozzarella & provolone cheeses!
Fish & Chips- $13.95
Two pieces of beer battered cod, with steak fries and cole slaw.
Calzones and Rolls
Sausage Roll- $5.95 each
A delicious blend of sausage, sautéed peppers and onions & mozzarella “rolled” up in our own dough.
Salami, pepperoni, cappacollo, mushroom, mozzarella & provolone pin wheeled in dough.
Cheese Calzones- $6.75 sm. & $10.75 lg.
A delicious blend of ricotta & mozzarella cheeses. Stuffings- $1.00/$2.00, *premium stuff is double $.
NY Style Cheese Pizza- 14”- $12.25 & 16”-$14.25
By the Slice- $2.25 (cheese)
Sicilian Style Cheese Pizza- $17.25
By the Slice- $2.75 (cheese)
Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza Crust- 12” for $12.00
Whole toppings- $2.25 Half toppings- $1.25 Slice toppings- $.75
-Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Peppers, Olives (Black or Green), Ham, Pineapple, Tomato, Spinach, Garlic, Extra Cheese, Bacon, Sliced Meatball, Onion, Salami, Pepperoncini, Jalapeno, *Roasted Red Peppers, *Chicken, *Artichoke, *Hatch Chile-
(*Premium toppings are double $)
(Don’t forget we do take & bake pizza too!)
Fresh mozzarella, marinara & topped with fresh basil leaves.
White Pizza- $13.25/$15.25
A delicious blend of garlic, butter & ricotta cheese. (Also available by the slice.)
Chicken Cacciatore Pizza- $18.00/$19.50
Delicious chicken marinated with peppers, mushrooms & onions covered with a layer of mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Wing Pizza- $18.00/$19.50
Chicken breast meat layered over our pizza & wing sauces covered with mozzarella & bleu cheese crumbles.
Tree Cheese- $15.25/$17.25
A delicious blend of feta, provolone & mozzarella!
B-B-Q Pizza- $18.00/$19.50
B-B-Q sauce (of course) with chicken, jalapenos, fresh tomatoes, bacon & mozzarella cheese.
Ask about our special pizza of the week!
Dinners and Entrees
(Add an americano salad for $3.00, or a specialty salad for $4.00)
Spaghetti or Penne- $8.95
Add meatball or sausage for $3.00 * Sub Pesto, ala Vodka, Alfredo or Bolognese Sauces for $1.75
A hearty portion of our homemade meat lasagna.
Baked Penne- $11.95
Penne pasta with ricotta cheese smothered in sauce & melted mozzarella.
Jumbo round cheese filled.
Homemade crepes stuffed with our special seasoned ricotta cheese.
Eggplant ala Pisa- $15.95
Layers of eggplant, ricotta, tomato & spinach covered in sauce & cheese w/ a side of pasta.
Fettucini Chicken Alfredo- $16.95
Delicious chicken & veggies with alfredo sauce.
Cutlet ala Parmigiana- $18.95 (veal) $16.95 (chicken)
Tender veal or chicken cutlet covered in sauce & mozzarella w/ a side of pasta.
Zuppa de Pesce- $17.95
A delightful stew clams, mussels, shrimp & calamari over a bed of fettuccini.
Specialty of the Day ala Nicantoni- ???
Sweet endings, Desserts
Authentic NY Crumb Cake- $5.95
Cheese Cake- $5.95
Black and White Cookie- $4.95
Mini Cannoli plate- $4.95/3
Specialty Desserts- $6.95
(Wait till you see our famous dessert tray.)
Cocktails ala Buono
Mafia's Kiss - $8.50
A delicious blend of disoronno, peach liqueur, & sweet & sour.
Brooklyn Egg Cream- $7.50
Just like the old days, but for grown-ups.
Long Island Iced Tea- $9.00
Need we say more?
Hudson Bay Breeze- $10.00
This will get you where you want to go! Seagram’s 7, malibu rum & cranberry juice.
New York Apple- $10.00
10, 9, 8, 7, 6, etc! Apple pucker schnapps, grape vodka & cranberry juice.
Bocce Ball- $8.00
Disaronno, orange juice & a pallina (cherry).
Thank you for visiting us. It has been Nicantoni’s pleasure of serving you. We also have many catering options should the need arise. Please contact us for any catering needs or special events you want to plan on our patio. We also deliver with DoorDash via our website at www.nicantonis.com. If you have any questions or comments, call us directly at 480-892-2234 or email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Try our new onion frizzles for $4.95